Tuesday, March 30, 2010
The Season to Move On
The experience has been great and I want to wholeheartedly thank Jonathan, Judi, and the rest of the crew I've worked with at Illuminata, my fellow analysts at other firms, and of course our clients over the years. I learned a lot, had a ball, met many people who I count as friends, assisted companies large and small, and have no regrets about having spent the majority of the last ten years at Illuminata.
All that said, and sincerely meant, the season is changing. I echo many of Andi Mann's sentiments upon leaving Enterprise Management Associates (EMA) to join CA. We're in a period of enormous change in IT. That always seems to be the case but we're seeing some particularly fundamental shifts in the way that applications are delivered and infrastructures are operated. Vendors are re-aligning in response. There are new horsemen.
I wanted to be involved in those changes in a more hands-on way than was possible as an analyst, a job that is inherently a bit academic and outside-looking-in. (Indeed that somewhat detached perspective is one of the values that industry analysts bring to those in the trenches.) It's been a great ride but I'm looking forward to being back on the vendor side of things as I was during my earlier career at Data General. There were many things I liked about being an industry analyst, but I did miss working with development teams and being directly involved with bringing products to market.
To cut to the chase, Red Hat has offered me the position of Senior Cloud Strategy Marketing and Evangelism Manager out of the Westford MA office and I have accepted. I'll be helping to develop and implement Red Hat's cloud business and marketing strategy. It's a very exciting opportunity at a great company that puts me right in the thick of the changes I mentioned above.
I'll be taking a few weeks off and will go largely off the Net during that time. However, once I plug back in, I plan to remain very involved with many of the communities in which I participate. I will remain on twitter (@ghaff). I will continue to write my personal blog (and likely other blogs as well although this is among the details that need ironing out). I expect to spend lots of time out and about. I look forward to continuing to work and talk with many of you, albeit from a different perspective and in a different role.
I’d like to close by again thanking the many clients who I have had the honor of working for and with over the years. Illuminata and I appreciated the purchase orders, sure. But you’ve also helped me learn and provided intellectual stimulation along with many good times. Illuminata remains at your service and, although I will no longer be an analyst, I look forward to our paths crossing in the future as well.
Monday, March 22, 2010
Links for 03-22-2010
- Star Investor Vinod Khosla Responds : Greentech Media - Ooh. I got quoted by Vinod Khosla!
- Op-Ed Contributor - The Age of Concrete - NYTimes.com - "If one society worshiped God in stone, and another venerated enterprise in steel, it must say something that we have now been able to reach so high with our most common building material: concrete."
- Up next: Cloud computing management - TotalCIO - The rise of cloud management vendors. (The "first wave" was more about virtualization management vendors sticking "cloud" in their presos.)
- William Vambenepe — “Freeing SaaS from Cloud”: slides and notes from Cloud Connect keynote - Generally agree with this. In a lot of cases, you really do need to talk about SaaS differently from IaaS/PaaS.
- Hard questions about open source software | Blog | Bob Sutor
Friday, March 19, 2010
Links for 03-19-2010
- A small and unscientific exploration of OSS license use | carlodaffara.conecta.it - I'm not sure the delta in committers is statistically significant. Interesting data to augment the Black Duck figures thought.
- Amanpour to ABC’s This Week; A Good Change, or a Waste of Talent? - Tuned In - TIME.com - I lost interest in the Sunday morning talk shows sometime around when David Brinkley retired.
- Data Center Dialog: Connecting some dots from Cloud Connect: everyone was "all in" - Good rundown on the CloudConnect event.
- Wikipedia, Notability, and Open Source Software | A chronicle of Ubuntard stupidity. - "Of course, the Association of Deletionist Imbeciles have their little size breakdown, which implies it’s difficult to find what you want when more content exists. Clearly, these people have not heard of search algorithms."
- Will Cloud Computing Make Personal Computers Obsolete? | 1-800-Recycling - Seems to overstate case. Makes clients less stateful but could argue that makes for more clients rather than fewer or less often replaced ones.
Thursday, March 18, 2010
Some Thoughts on Going from Exchange to Gmail
Over the Christmas holidays, my employer, Illuminata, migrated from Exchange to Gmail. The main impetus was that Exchange worked OK—until it didn’t. And then it was a major crisis to get email up and running again. We made the move to Google Apps with the aid of a local consultant and it went smoothly for the most part; the main issues weren’t directly related to moving off Exchange but with associated changes in our IT infrastructure. Here are my impressions after a couple of months.
Gmail uses a fundamentally different organizational scheme from Exchange/Outlook. It uses labels while Exchange uses hierarchical folders. Generally speaking I find labels/tags/keywords to be a better approach because many items don’t lend themselves to a strict hierarchy. However, a lot of people are used to a hierarchical system that mimics physical file folders and filing cabinets. Furthermore, some things—such as those related to client projects, business transactions, and so forth—really do work better as a formal hierarchy. You can do some things to mimic a hierarchy using labels but it can be a bit of a force fit.
Unsurprisingly, Gmail organization is also built around search and, in fact, doesn’t give you a way to sort other than by the default newest to oldest. Mostly I’m fine with this; the searching works great. However, when cleaning out my mailbox in Outlook, I found it handy to sort by name as a way to quickly delete or archive a lot of recurring emails from a single source. (Yes, I’m aware that I can use Outlook and other desktop clients with Gmail but I try to just stick with the Web interface.)
As someone who uses a fair number of different clients, I really like having a very functional Web interface wherever I am. Exchange has a decent fat client in Outlook—which I have installed on a couple of systems—but otherwise you’re stuck with a Web interface that’s mediocre, especially if you don’t use Internet Explorer. Furthermore, using Outlook meant that I needed a working VPN connection which often breaks in hoteld and at conferences for a variety of reasons.
The calendar in Google Apps works nicely, including for shared calendars. I find it a bit quicker to enter events than with Outlook though the difference isn’t that great. Again, though, the Web interface is much better than accessing Exchange through a Web interface.
One area where Google Apps is weak is contacts which is sort of messily tied to email. I’d really prefer to have a dedicated contact database of some sort. (I think part of the problem is that the import from Exchange wasn’t especially clean.)
Overall, after living with it for a couple of months, it’s not perfect but I definitely prefer it. The Web interface may be the biggest win but the ease of searching is nice too given that I’ve never been especially good at manually organizing.
(Overall, the office is more split on the move. The people who don’t like it are probably most bothered by the move from a folder hierarchy to labels which does require some mental reorganization and, as I said, isn’t as good a model for certain things.)
Links for 03-18-2010
- The Official Netflix Blog: Friends Update - Wasn't something I used but seems counter general trends to kill social recommendation.
- Brocade’s unraveling - "The OEM channel is popular in tech because it removes the expense and exasperation of selling to end-users. You work with fellow engineers at the OEM to qualify the product and their sales people do the work. You don’t think you need much marketing – really, you do, but few realize that – and very few sales people. And the sales people you do need are the cool, savvy relationship cultivators, not the high-pressure closers. It’s almost all good. The bad is the loss of control. Other people position you, test you, support you and ultimately use you for their gain. That can work well if, like DEC early on, your widget is buried inside another product and you’re free to market to end-users."
- How Privacy Vanishes Online, a Bit at a Time - NYTimes.com - "But Jon Kleinberg, a professor of computer science at Cornell University who studies social networks, is skeptical that rules will have much impact. His advice: “When you’re doing stuff online, you should behave as if you’re doing it in public — because increasingly, it is.”"
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Links for 03-17-2010
- 451 CAOS Theory » On the fall and rise of the GNU GPL - I'd summarize this as "Things haven't really changed much."
- How students use Wikipedia - I find this a generally encouraging study as it indicates that (at college level anyway) Wikipedia gets used as one source of information rather than the single canonical source.
- What is LR-DIMM , LRDIMM Memory ? ( Load-Reduce DIMM)
- Decline of Food Critics: WSJ Loses a Restaurant Reviewer - TIME - "Now, thanks to all the things the ancient regime most loathes — the Food Network, Top Chef, Eater and other blogs, Tony Bourdain, Momofuku mania, Rachael Ray, celebrity-chef restaurants — America has become as turned on by food as any Ford-era gourmand. But they lack the one thing that the old guard has in spades: perspective."
- Beyond The Hurt Locker: The 10 Greatest War Movies (Ever) - Jinni Blog - Not a bad list though I'd probably put Das Boot and All Quiet on the Western Front in there somewhere (probably instead of Platoon and maybe Full Metal Jacket.
- Is Jaron Lanier just a hater, or should we be paying attention? | opensource.com - "Jaron is definitely channeling Ayn Rand when it comes to his belief in the importance of the individual creator, which explains why he dislikes Wikipedia so much. I think he makes some good points, especially regarding the dangers of anonymous authorship (leads to lack of accountability) and the need for transparency in authorship (certainly not one of Wikipedia's strengths)."
Tuesday, March 16, 2010
Links for 03-16-2010
- In Cloud, ITIL, and SOE – Heterogeneity is the New Standard | Andi Mann – Übergeek - Agree. Cloud computing isn't just anything you apply the term to but academic purity often gets in the way of useful implementations in real life.
- Visual Guide to NoSQL Systems - Nathan Hurst's Blog - Good discussion in the comments as well.
- Airport Guide by iFly - $3.99 - 10 iPhone apps for frequent fliers - CNET Reviews - I have a somewhat different list but I may check some of these out.
- This Changes Everything - Chuck's Blog - Chuck Hollis' recap of EMC's virtual storage event.
- Amazon auctions computing power: Clouds under the hammer | The Economist - I'm wary about conflating Amazon's spot pricing with markets in computing cycles more broadly.
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Links for 03-10-2010
- A Short Documentary on Google - What is Google Trying to do?
- Playing games in Google Earth | Google Earth Blog
- 137 Years of Future - The Long Now Blog - Popular Science has put their historical archive online.
- Sharing Hotel Info Is Critical For Business Travelers - Business Travel - Portfolio.com - Some good advice about using sites with user-created reviews.
- Video: Cloud Computing in Government… | Rational Survivability
- The history of the Mainframe computer
- tecosystems » Who’s Winning the Cloud Marketing Battle? - A simple metric yes, but at least a second order relevant one.
- FlightCaster - Flight prediction delays. Something to give a whirl.
- Second Life's virtual money can become real-life cash - washingtonpost.com - Most people I know tried and abandoned Second Life long ago. But it's still chugging along at a good clip.
Monday, March 08, 2010
Links for 03-08-2010
- Rough Type: Nicholas Carr's Blog: Nowness - "There are times when human beings are able to correct the bias of a technology. There are other times when we make the bias of an instrument our own. Everything we've seen in the development of the Net over the past 20 years, and, indeed, in the development of mass media over the past 50 years, indicates that what we’re seeing today is an example of the latter phenomenon. We are choosing nowness over ripeness."
- RSA Interview (c/o Tripwire) On the State Of Information Security In Virtualized/Cloud Environments. | Rational Survivability
- Red Hat Cloud Business Unit | Virtually Speaking | ZDNet.com - Appropriate cautions.
- Adapters: Micro 4/3 - Interesting, Micro 4/3 adapters for many types of older lenses.
- Data Center Strategies: Client Virtualization: Where Does It Fit? - "If the customer has already deployed a good application virtualization and desktop management solution (e.g. Symantec Altiris, Microsoft Desktop Optimization Pack, or Novell Zenworks), moving to a virtual desktop infrastructure may not save much money in the long run. Moving to a desktop virtualization solution has to be a strategic (business) decision not a tactical (IT) one."
- Press Gang § SEEDMAGAZINE.COM - Tricky questions. In this day and age, saying that a journalist only works for a "publication" doesn't work. But neither does saying anyone with a "laptop and WiFi connection" is.
- Your Favourite Technology Will Not Kill Anything | Andi Mann – Übergeek - "Even if, as Gartner predicts, by 2012, 20 percent of businesses will own no IT assets – which I find highly dubious; and even if the cloud computing market will be worth $160bn by 2011 – also somewhat dubious; then still a vast majority of organizations will continue to own their IT assets. Even allowing for some substantial private cloud deployment (much less dubious), there is no chance cloud computing will kill the on-premise, installed and owned, IT environment."
- Voice recognition gets "cloudy," but is it the "new touch"? - "As someone who has used speech recognition regularly for years on multiple platforms, this future is "within sight" in the same way that I can see the moon out my window every night. Still, that's something, and anyone who tried to use voice recognition before, say, 2005 will be shocked by its capabilities and actual usefulness today. As companies like Microsoft, Google, and Nuance deploy more voice services that live in the cloud and not on a local machine, advances in understanding should accelerate—an exciting prospect for anyone (*cough* Editor in Chief Ken Fisher *cough*) who has ever had speech recognition software turn "but the fields" into "blood to feel.""
Friday, March 05, 2010
Links for 03-05-2010
- Elliott Associates and Novell: All About a Game of Cat and Mouse - ConsortiumInfo.org - Good read although I wonder if here, as elsewhere, the importance of SUSE Linux in the dynamics aren't being overstated (e.g. because of the rise of Ubuntu).
- Cloudonomics.com - "In a nutshell S+S is a model which embraces both traditional on premise IT and the functionality provided by the cloud – letting the user decide whether they want to use online or on-premise functionality, or a combination of the two. It’s a salient approach as, in reality, most companies will use a mix of traditional IT and cloud services. Over the next few years the wider IT industry will come to acknowledge that cloud is not an ‘all or nothing’ proposition." More complicated than just economics of course.
- Collective Conversation » ARcade » Blog Archive » Grappling with the Cloud – What the Analysts Say (and why their opinion matters) - "In a nutshell S+S is a model which embraces both traditional on premise IT and the functionality provided by the cloud – letting the user decide whether they want to use online or on-premise functionality, or a combination of the two. It’s a salient approach as, in reality, most companies will use a mix of traditional IT and cloud services. Over the next few years the wider IT industry will come to acknowledge that cloud is not an ‘all or nothing’ proposition."
- The Cloud Market: EC2 Statistics - Ubuntu presence not a surprise. Share of plain Debian (assuming that's being reported accurately) is.
- Dennis Forbes on Software and Technology - Getting Real about NoSQL and the SQL-Isn't-Scalable Lie - "[Though as Michael Stonebraker points out, SQL the query language actually has remarkably little to actually to do with the debate. It would be more clearly called NoACID]"
- Network Profile of the Day… Gary Kindall & CP/M - Prof. Boerner's Explorations
- The Argument for Dirt-Cheap E-Books | BNET Technology Blog | BNET - I don't agree with everything here but provocative discussion of ebook pricing.
- Data Center Dialog: Going rogue, cloud computing-style: what you can learn by going around IT - "But most interestingly, we also discussed the truly amazing tendency that people in even in the most conservative IT organizations have to, well, “go rogue.” In some of the most locked-down IT environments, folks try innovative stuff on their own, even when it doesn’t meet all of their strict requirements. Why? To help them get their job done in a much better or faster way."
- Cloud Security Takes A Big Leap Forward - Chuck's Blog - Some good discussion of a security architecture for virtualized environments.
- 5 things VMware must do to fend off Microsoft
- Observations on film art : Motion-capturing an Oscar - "With all the kinds of changes that I’ve pointed out, how would Academy members be supposed to judge these performances were they to be nominated in the traditional acting categories? Where is the boundary between acting and special effects? Despite actors’ and directors’ claims to the contrary, the movements and expressions caught by performance capture are changed in many obvious and not so obvious ways. A close inspection of the comparison photos reveals the details of the transformation, but in watching the film, the viewer cannot necessarily gauge what sorts of changes were made. I can well imagine that actors like Meryl Streep or Jeff Bridges would be justified if they objected to competing in the same Oscar category as what are essentially hybrid performances seamlessly combining the original acting and the digital transformation."
Monday, March 01, 2010
Links for 03-01-2010
- The A4 and the A8: secrets of the iPad's brain - "The second, and perhaps most likely reason behind Apple's silence, is that the A4 just isn't anything to write home about—and on this second point, I actually know a thing or two. If Apple were to tell you what's in the A4, most of the focus would be on what the chip is not, rather than on what the iPad is."
- 48 best free software downloads from Microsoft | News | TechRadar UK
- Sysinternals Suite
- Oracle wields hefty muscle in Colorado's tech sector - The Denver Post
- Upgrade the Windows 7 RC to any retail version « Icrontic Tech - A couple of hacks to let you upgrade the Windows 7 RC to the Home Premium retail version.
- From the Desk of David Pogue - Photoshop and Photography - When Is It Real? - NYTimes.com - Good list.
- Should the analysts be blogging? « The IIAR Blog - A lot of good thinking here.
Tuesday, February 23, 2010
Links for 02-23-2010
- Can a Chameleon Change its Spots? » ocb - Citrix Community - "If the use case involves the customer buying, installing and running Linux to achieve virtualization, KVM will eventually do a fine job. If on the other hand, the user expects to deploy a virtualization platform that is entirely guest OS agnostic, using a complete virtual infrastructure platform then a type-1 hypervisor that is OS agnostic (xen.org Xen Cloud Platform, Citrix XenServer, OracleVM, VMware vSphere) is what they will go for. I have previously made the case that OS-bundled hypervisors have both inherent advantages and disadvantages in penetrating the market:" I don't necessarily disagree but ease of acquisition is a big factor here too as many technologies become 'good enough.'
- Matrix: Impacts to Alumni Organizations In A World of Social Networks « Web Strategy by Jeremiah Owyang | Social Media, Web Marketing - Interesting discussion of how Alumni Associations fit with social media. Good insight that (at least from the perspective of alumni), associations are largely middlemen.
- It's the End of Cisco As We Know It (CSCO) - "I don't know how Cisco could ever repair the damage it's causing to its own heart and soul these days. That might sound like a heap of touchy-feely hippie talk to ardent Cisco investors, but I truly believe that Cisco is heading down a wrong track that will inflict serious damage on its lofty stock price. Furthermore, it's way too late to do anything about it."
- The key to Apple's success? Focus | The Open Road - CNET News - "For start-ups and earlier-stage companies, focus is the key driver for growth, because it allows an organization to pull together in the same direction. Which direction it is is far less important than choosing a direction to attack."
- Novell and Red Hat: Taking Linux to the Cloud | Open Source Journal - "It is interesting to see how Open source rivals Red Hat and Novell have transferred their Linux warfare to the cloud. As both companies seek to use their open source history to advantage on the web platform by spouting standard mantras about avoiding vendor lock-ins and low cost, they have also taken different approaches on other counts when taking their cloud services to market."
- Observations on changes in the analyst ecosystem » SageCircle Blog
- Olympus and Panasonic rumors - As some of you know, this is one of the most interasting areas of camera development to me right now.
- Search is the Web's fun and wicked problem - O'Reilly Radar - "
Search is the Web's most powerful and frustrating tool." - tecosystems » Maemo + Moblin = MeeGo: The Q&A - "Q: You’re arguing, then, that purpose built devices are the rule, rather than the exception here?
A: Certainly seems that way. There appear to be two general user paradigms: general purpose, and device. " There are degrees within device certainly (e.g. app store model vs. fixed function) but the basic point, I think, holds. - SF Signal: SF Fanatic: Current Science Fiction On Television - Agree more than I disagree with this rundown (though I haven't watched everything listed).
- Data center hardware wars: VARs take on vendors - "VARs and integrators take a different view on that "one-throat" mantra for data center hardware. Said one East Coast Cisco and HP VAR: "Absolutely, customers want one vendor, but we're the vendor! They're working with us to build a multi-vendor solution that suits their needs." " This is an area of real tention with the vendor drive towards more integrated systems.
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Links for 02-18-2010
- The dark side of geo: PleaseRobMe.com | The Social - CNET News - I'm not quite sure what to think of this. On the one hand, I don't really see it as a problem today. On the other, though, we've probably only seen the tip of the implications associated with massive public mashing up of personal information.
- Getting Geeked for ‘Glee’ - ArtsBeat Blog - NYTimes.com - "If you’re yearning for a television series where religious attention to picayune details isn’t mandatory (and which isn’t “Gossip Girl”), the folks at Fox have provided this preview of coming episodes of “Glee,” which returns to the network’s schedule in April." Much as I like the intricate serial dramas on TV, there is a very real limit to my bandwidth for that kind of show.
- The Online Photographer: We Hear From Harlan - "
Well, to my surprise, yesterday I got a delightful little note back, typed on a tiny square of paper (reproduced here more or less actual size), no doubt with the ancient manual Olympia typewriter Harlan is famous for continuing to be faithful to. Pronouncing himself "pleased and stunned," he says "YOU are the first—the VERY FIRST—mensch & Good Guy to ever send me a payment for the work YouTube, et al, have mis-appropriated." " - Clay Shirky: Doing work, or Doing Work? | blog@CACM | Communications of the ACM
- SFFaudio - Science fiction audiobooks.
Monday, February 15, 2010
Links for 02-15-2010
- John Nack on Adobe: Adobe is "sabotaging" HTML5?? - The response seems fair as far as it goes although it's also true that as someone notes in the comments: "Adobe has made it *extremely* easy for people to believe this kind of thing, and it's almost entirely self-inflicted. When you look at the Flash team's response to criticism, the tone is really clear: "Flash is doing just great, and if you don't like it, you're some kind of Steve Jobs Flavor-Aid swilling nutbar. You can't have the internet without flash, and if you think otherwise, you're a fanatic.""
- Test Your Geography Knowledge
- Metropolis: The Restored Sci-Fi Masterpiece, Streaming Live Now (For the First Time!) - Techland - TIME.com - Apparently a restored (with much thought lost footage) version of Metropolis debuted at the Berlin Film Festival.
- Coding Horror: International Backup Awareness Day - "Don't rely on your host or anyone else to back up your important data. Do it yourself. If you aren't personally responsible for your own backups, they are effectively not happening."
- FRONTLINE: digital nation: watch the full program | PBS - “I teach the most brilliant students in the world,” says MIT professor and clinical psychologist Sherry Turkle, who describes the challenges of teaching students who are surfing the Internet and texting during class. “But they have done themselves a disservice by drinking the Kool-Aid and believing that a multitasking learning environment will serve their best purposes. There are just some things that are not amenable to being thought about in conjunction with 15 other things.”
- Things that Make me go Hmm - A chart showing just how small Xbox (and for that matter online services) are in the context of Microsoft as a whole.
- Galleries / Photography / High Speed | Fubiz™ - Colorful high speed photos.
- Giz Explains: Why ISO Is the New Megapixel - Digital Cameras - Gizmodo
- dtoy_vs_byokal - A virtual kaleidoscope.
Friday, February 12, 2010
Links for 02-12-2010
- Cool Tools: TeleKast - Open source teleprompter software. Sounds like it could be handy for vblogs.
- Irving Wladawsky-Berger: Extreme Scale Computing - "Finally, it is important not to underestimate the impact of exascale breakthroughs to more capacity oriented machines, as well as to smaller machines that share the same technologies, architecture, software and applications. Many of the innovation that will enable us to develop exascale class supercomputers will yield relatively inexpensive petascale class systems as well as smaller ones. The wider the access to such families of systems, the richer the overall ecosystem including applications, users and technologies."
- What's Right With Reality TV - TIME - "The Jersey Shore--ites have never known a world in which hooking up drunk in a house paid for by a Viacom network was not an option."
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
Links for 02-10-2010
- The Red Line Tour of Innovation in Boston - Innovation Economy - Boston.com
- Studio Lighting Tutorials » StudioLighting.net
- Light Right - A Crash Course In Lighting Video, John Jackman
- DIY Light Kit | Backyard FX
- Once More unto the Breach: IT Customer Buying Patterns and Vendor Competition - "Novell's opportunities aren't around offering cheaper support, but have to be looking forward to the next ground they can grab in customers's minds."
- Top 10 Super Bowl tech ads
Tuesday, February 09, 2010
Where does Analyst Blogging Belong?
Around the end of last week, Carter Lusher kicked off a mini-firestorm (among the rather small percentage of the Internet that cares about Industry Analysts) by reporting that Forrester Research was apparently implementing some new blogging policies.
I’ll let you read Josh Bernoff’s post for the details but basically:
- Posts pertaining to an analyst’s area of research are now to be posted on Forrester’s Web site
- Analysts can continue to maintain personal blogs on topics that are not related to their work at Forrester
Now, some of the reaction seems to have been an initial knee-jerk response to Carter’s initial posting that left open the possibility that Forrester was banning personal blogs period. This seemed unlikely to me but, until Forrester PR fleshed out the specifics of the policy changes, it’s what a lot of people assumed. And it’s very understandable why a lot of people (including myself) would have considered such to be way over the line.
I understand the negative reaction to the actual policy far less. I tend to try to stay out of these meta-blogging and meta-analyst topics but I’ve been having a fair bit of back-channel conversation on this, so I wanted to just summarize a few thoughts here.
As many of you reading this probably know, I work for a boutique industry analyst firm, Illuminata. And I blog.
I started blogging on my own site in 2003. Truth be told, I started in part to give a bit of a kick in the pants to an Illuminata blogging platform project that was taking longer to get going than I would have liked.
We soon got our official blog going and that’s where I post my short-form Illuminata research that happens to be published using a blog (Wordpress) technology platform. I continue to also post on my personal site; many of those postings still relate to technology but of a sort, such as consumer product reviews, that are not appropriate as Illuminata research.
And, make no mistake, when an analyst publishes a blog related to their coverage area, it is viewed as research. It may be shorter. It may be less formal. It may be published under tighter time constraints. But I assure you that if I make a factual error or state an opinion that doesn’t sit well with someone, no one at that vendor cares that it was published in a blog rather than a research note.
(Yes, there is some level of understanding that short, quick pieces may not go through as rigorous a review process and may not provide as complete a context for the opinions expressed as a longer piece, but my basic point stands.)
I write all this as preamble to the point that we never had any real discussion about the assumption that when we wrote about topics pertaining to Illuminata focus areas, we would publish those on Illuminata’s site rather than our own. For one thing, it seemed clear that we were producing this work as an employee and it belonged under the Illuminata brand—with our bylines.
The other thing though is that I don’t think I would necessarily have even wanted to combine it with my personal blog. Illuminata aggregated our enterprise IT writings in a way that provided a certain critical mass and awareness. In addition, although I know not everyone feels this way, I like the freedom to have some leeway with my own blog. That doesn’t mean I think I can say and write anything with impunity. But it does mean I can post some vacation pictures or make a political statement without worrying that doing so would be out of place in a 'professional blog. For me, maintaining at least some nominal separation between personal and professional has merit. (Although, to be sure, I don’t do so on twitter.)
And while different firms may have different policies, Illuminata’s approach seems pretty typical to me. Even where the blogs and analysts are most clearly individualistic, there’s usually a very clear connection to the firm name and brand.
I have come to see points on the other side of this argument as it’s raged over the past few days. For example, I can understand the reluctance of someone with a well-established personal/professional blog to abandon it upon joining a firm. And I can understand why an analyst would like to take their content with them if they leave. However, I don’t think it’s too cavalier to note that when people, especially high-profile people, join or leave organizations that often forces changes to what they can say, where they can say it, and how they present themselves in public.
It’s easy to see why people react instinctively to what they perceive as a stifling of individuality. And perhaps, as some commenters have suggested, these policies about blogging reflect deeper cultural or policy shift; I don’t know. But in the end, a policy that puts analyst research on the analyst site doesn’t sound unreasonable.
Friday, February 05, 2010
Links for 02-05-2010
- Albert Exergian's modernist TV posters | Television & radio | The Guardian - Great examples of really distilling down a concept.
- WCBS NEWSRADIO 880 - Heinz Revamps Ketchup Packets - This is actually pretty cool in a way that makes you ask why this wasn't done years ago.
- Amazon vs. Apple: What Should E-Book Prices Be? - The Atlantic Business Channel - The price elasticity is the big question here. The other side of the argument is that because people have limited time, they'll only buy so many books no matter how cheap they are.
- Dollhouse - Big Dumb Object - Agreed. When I first looked, it didn't hook me. (In general, I'm less amazed by Whedon's stuff than many seem to be.) But the second season got quite good. I also agree that the way TV works in the US, many good series continue on for way too many beats.
Tuesday, February 02, 2010
Links for 02-02-2010
- Is BYOPC Really Key to Attracting Millennials? | Andi Mann – Übergeek - "This then has significant implications for CIOs and others looking at BYOPC. Despite the validity (or otherwise) of any other claims in favour of BYOPC, no organization should be looking to BYOPC to attract and retain staff from the echo boom generation. They would be better off looking at a dozen or more other important factors than spending the significant time, effort, and money on implementing a BYOPC program."
- Panopticlick - Your browser fingerprint may be unique.
- Why People Don't Check Voicemail Anymore - well, that, and Go... on Twitpic - Yep, about right.
- New Echo Nest APIs demoed at the Stockholm Music Hackday « Music Machinery
- ‘Calvin and Hobbes’ Creator Speaks - ArtsBeat Blog - NYTimes.com - "It’s not quite as impressive as scoring, say, the last known interview with J. D. Salinger, but The Cleveland Plain Dealer has landed what is believed to be the first interview in nearly 20 years with Bill Watterson, the reclusive creator of the comic strip “Calvin and Hobbes.” "
- Apple's iPad vs. Amazon's Kindle: It's not zero sum | Between the Lines | ZDNet.com - "Frankly, I just want a series of paperthin screens that can tether to one computing device and break off depending on the use case I needed at that very minute. We’re building an arsenal of gadgets largely over the size of a screen." Interesting thought although plug-and-play modularity of this sort is very hard to get right. And, so long as we use the iTunes sync model, I'm not sure there's a big win in that modularity. (The big problem with multiple computers is their "care and feeding.")
Friday, January 29, 2010
Links for 01-29-2010
- tecosystems » Sunset: The Oracle Acquisition Q&A - Good analysis as usual from Stephen. Nothing here I'd argue with.
- Dartblog: "Outsourcing: Turn the Inn Around" - Note that this is the same college that also still uses its own highly manual payroll system.
- http://www.thevirtualcircle.com/2010/01/sun-microsystems-oracles-swiss-army-knife-of-vengeance/ - A few things in here make be go huh???? but worth reading.
- The Apple iPad: It's just ahead of its time | Molly Rants - CNET News - I mostly agree with Molly. I still tend to think of this class of device as a tweener but it's also reasonable to think instead of a smartphone, tablet, and laptop as being 3 different types of devices.
- Inbox Zero is Overrated - I generally agree with all this. While many of us need to stay reasonably on top of email, we need to be aware of the cost of context switches and turn things off as appropriate.
The Obligatory iPad Post
I wasn’t going to write anything about the iPad. I spent the afternoon of the launch watching a 5 hour Webcast about the Oracle acquisition of Sun closing. And then I needed to file a piece with CNET. So, while I more or less followed the iPad details via twitter, I had neither the time nor especially the interest to do a serious write-up with so much other punditry already out there.
But I’ve been getting the usual stream of questions from friends and family so I’m going to put down a few thoughts to avoid answering the same thing over and over again. Take these in the vein of observations and preliminary assessments based on how I would probably want to use such a device. I have no interest in whether you buy one or not. As IBM’s Bob Sutor pus it: “No one is forcing anyone to get an iPad. If you don't want or need one, don't get one. Pretty simple, no?”
Price. This may have been the biggest upside surprise of the announcement—both the purchase price and the price for no-contract 3G networking: “Starting at $499.” That said, the sweet spot is probably the 32GB model with 3G at that’s $729 (or add another $100) for 64GB. Now add $29/month for unlimited data 3G networking and we’re up up a 2 year cost-of-ownership of over $1,400.
Screen. It’s LCD and to reiterate what I wrote recently: “Current LCD technology may serve for some first-generation devices but it draws too much power and you can’t read it easily in sunlight. E-paper on the other hand is currently black-and-white and is only suited for images (such as text pages) that aren’t changing quickly. This limitations lead to rather silly devices like this. There is lots of interesting work going on by companies such as Pixel Qi and Qualcomm (mirasol)—expect to see interesting demos at CES—but actual product is in the future.” An LCD display isn’t bad per se, but I think we need to get beyond them for a truly compelling device in this form factor. Apple is essentially beholden to the technology that’s available and it’s no easy problem for a multi-use device. The needs of games and video are much different from the needs of books.
Touch screen. As just about everyone expected, the iPad uses a capacitive multi-touch display. In other words, you use your fingers. This is what just about everyone expected; it’s basically a big iPhone or iPod Touch. That’s fine but it means that you can’t write on the screen with a stylus as you do with a resistive touch screen. Now, with this size of screen, applications that let you write with your finger may be practical for serious note taking. I’d have to try it and see. Dan Bricklin (yes, that Dan Bricklin) has a nifty app in this vein for the iPhone.
No camera. A no op as far as I’m concerned. Everyone has (a mediocre) one in their phone already. And how many people really use video chat—leaving aside the ergonomic issues associated with using one for that purpose in a tablet?
Locked down operating system with app store. I don’t have a particular issue with this so long as the apps I need are available. The lack of Flash in a browser is a serious limitation today; you have to have a high-fidelity browser experience in a device basically designed for browsing. So is the lack of multitasking which doesn’t bother me much in my iPhone but seems more problematic in a bigger device. I expect the more serious limitations to get resolved over time. Ultimately if you want a general purpose operating system, this won’t be the choice for you.
Real-world battery life. TBD. I suspect it won’t be as good as I would like; no portable gadget with an LCD screen has good enough battery life.
For the record, I’m a big believer in this category of device. But some of the technology isn’t really there yet. And there are certainly other gadgets, such as a micro 4/3 camera system, in the $1400 price range I would like but haven’t been able to justify the cost. Furthermore, as Tim Bray has noted, this isn’t really something that people can use to create content. Yet much of my day is spent writing and other such tasks, so I’m not sure in how many circumstances I could dump my laptop and take one of these with me instead.
Different people have different needs and will make different tradeoffs. If you routinely carry a laptop that you use mostly for browsing, reading, lightweight social media, and so forth this could be very attractive even in its current form.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Recipe: Blue Cheese Cauliflower Soup
I recently broke down and bought a KitchenAid immersion blender
Here's the first recipe I made with it.
Ingredients:
2 celery ribs, finely chopped
1 cauliflower, cut into 1-inch florets
3 TBS unsalted butter
3 cups chicken broth
1 cup milk
4 oz crumbled blue cheese
1/2 cup light cream or half-and-half
1/4 tsp white pepper
1/8 tsp salt
Purée cauliflower mixture with immersion blender and return to a simmer. (Alternatively, transfer to a blender or food processor in two batches.) Add cheese, cream, pepper, and salt and cook over low heat, whisking, until cheese is melted and soup is smooth, about 1 minute.
Lower fat milk and cream can be used as desired.
Links for 01-28-2010
- New DivaBlog: Assimilation begins...Oracle Censors Blogs.Sun.Com - "As part of this next phase of assimilation...Oracle recently made available the new rules for blogging. If you work for Snoracle starting now, you must obtain your manager's permission before each public posting that relates to work. In theory that means before every tweet. "
- Animated stereoviews of old Japan ::: Pink Tentacle - Recreating stereoviews with animated GIFs.
- 441 – Sense of POPOS: Secret Spaces of San Francisco « Strange Maps
- For The Love Of Culture | The New Republic - I sometimes disagree with certain aspecys of "free culture" but this is a long and thoughtful piece by Lessig and is worth a read, via @stshank
- McNealy's bittersweet memo bids good-bye to Sun | Deep Tech - CNET News
- 3D TV | Cracked.com - "But of course, we realize that we're kind of missing the point here. Manufacturers know there is one ready-made market for this device: technology early adopters." The thing is that this is actually a fairly straightforward assessment of how things stand.
"This is a group of people for whom the main benefit of their technology purchases is the act of purchasing itself. They enjoy shopping for and researching the latest technology, possibly as an artifact of the hunting instinct that thousands of years ago gave them a sense of satisfaction from slaying a woolly mammoth. The early adopters love the rush of waiting for the new toy to hit shelves, they love the smell of new plastic, the sight of styrofoam blocks and black cables bundled together with twisty ties." - Bubble Wrap celebrating its 50th birthday - U.S. business- msnbc.com - "Mostly, they like the sound it makes when they destroy it, piece by piece, which largely explains the appeal of Bubble Wrap, the stress reducer disguised as package cushioning that maintains an inexplicable hold on pop culture... Like many innovations, Bubble Wrap initially was conceived for an entirely different purpose. According to Aurichio, a New York City designer approached inventors Marc Chavannes and Al Fielding in the late 1950s with a proposal for creating textured wallpaper."
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Links for 01-26-2010
- A Year of Global Shipping Routes Mapped by GPS | Wired Science | Wired.com
- The making of the NYT’s Netflix graphic – The Society for News Design - Some background on how this graphic was made. via Hacking Netflix.
- 7 Sins of Online Video Instructional Design
- The Secret Diary of Steve Jobs : An anxious world awaits - Great photo for this post. "Yes, it will transform the media business, and by “transform” I mean it will put me in charge of it, the way the iPod put me in charge of the music industry. Yes, it will destroy cable TV and utterly transform the 60-year-old television industry, and again, by “transform,” I mean I’ll be in charge, because I’ll be the guy from whom you buy your shows — I’ll be the guy with whom the consumer forms a relationship. I’ll be the guy who has your credit card on file. So the cable carriers are dead."
- Cool Tools: Fifty Dangerous Things
- A Practical Guide to Sous Vide Cooking - This is fascinating.
- Christopher Blizzard · HTML5 video and H.264 – what history tells us and why we’re standing with the web - The case against H.264.